HOW MILD HYPBERBARIC OXYGEN WORKS AND WHY IT IS GOOD FOR OUR CHILDREN
By Julie A. Buckley, MD, FAAP
What does hyperbaric oxygen do?
Physicists figured out years ago that a gas under pressure is more likely to dissolve into liquid- in mild hyperbaric oxygen therapy, the gas is oxygen and the liquid is blood. But under pressure, oxygen doesnt just hook up to red blood cells the way were used to thinking about it, it also dissolves into the plasma. When that plasma circulates near dormant or injured tissue such as an autistic brain, a bruised muscle, a sprained tendon, or a surgical wound, the oxygen in the plasma dissolves further into the damaged area than the oxygen thats attached to the red blood cell in the conventional delivery system can.
How much is too little and how much is too much?
A little oxygen is room air- 21% FiO2- and it loads 93-98% of your red blood cells with oxygen every time they pass through your lungs. This keeps most of us going day in and day out. A lot of oxygen- virtually 100% FiO2- is what divers breathe from their tanks- and what they use in high pressure hard shell chambers at hospitals - its potentially explosive and can be toxic to your body if you get too much for too long. Higher pressures and high levels of oxygen can be necessary when treating a diver who has the bends and certain wounds that wont heal. But the world of hyperbaric medicine is learning that lower pressures and less oxygen seem to have excellent effect on multiple systems of our bodies. In particular, lower pressure appears to be more beneficial for the injured brain than higher pressure.
So, how much is just right?
Somewhere in between too little and too much is what the mild hyperbaric chamber does. It pressurizes us to 1.3 atmospheres of pressure, effectively like going to the bottom of an 11 foot swimming pool and hanging out there with air to breathe and ears that are equalized. The experience feels like what happens when a pilot pressurizes an airplane cabin. When we fly they increase the cabin pressure to maintain something close to room air for us while we are at altitude in the thin oxygen poor air of our friendly skies.
When we use a concentrator we enrich the oxygen in the chamber even more- the concentrator removes most of the nitrogen that is in room air delivering more concentrated O2 through a small accessory tube to which we can attach a mask if a child will wear it. The end result is something more than 21% FiO2 and less than 100% FiO2 and will vary depending on whether or not a child will wear a mask or sit near the accessory oxygen.
Experience indicates our children probably get about 40% FiO2 overall in the mild hyperbaric chamber with a concentrator on. Lower pressures and smaller increases in oxygen content like the environment generated in the mild chamber seem to be ideal for promoting healing of dormant and injured cells.
Oxygen- if a little is good, more is not necessarily better
Remember that a little oxygen is good, too much oxygen is toxic and can actually induce oxidative stress (impairing healing of any sort), and in between there somewhere is superb. This is true because the human bodys relationships with oxygen are almost all curvilinear- sigmoid s shapes, bell curves that start low, go high, and come back down low with increasing numbers across the bottom of the graph, so that there can actually be a bad effect from too much. If a little is good, more is not necessarily better is an important concept in mild hyperbaric oxygen therapy.
How does the increase in oxygen help my child?
Remember that first paragraph where increased pressure dissolved more oxygen into the plasma in addition to loading up all of the red blood cells? When that oxygen enriched plasma circulates near dormant or injured tissue such as an autistic or encephalopathic brain, a bruised muscle, a sprained tendon, or a surgical wound, the oxygen dissolves further into the damaged area than the oxygen thats attached to the red blood cell in the conventional room air way. It penetrates deeper, allowing for potential healing in a place that either wouldnt happen at all (the autistic or encephalopathic brain) or wouldnt happen for a while until the more superficial tissue heals first (the sprains and bruises and surgical wounds)
How do we know the oxygen actually does some healing?
Football fans know that Terrell Owens of the Philadelphia Eagles sustained an ankle fracture at the end of the 2004-2005 season that would traditionally have required a year to rehabilitate. However, he used his own mild hyperbaric chamber along with other therapy to go from surgery to playing in the Superbowl in six weeks. His recovery was extraordinary, and he excelled on the field.
We can look to apparent healing of the brain by monitoring its perfusion and activity. We can also monitor behaviors, response to stimuli (sensory function) and motor skills. Monitoring of perfusion and activity, of the relative numbers of dormant, sleeping or alert and functioning brain cells is done with a Brain SPECT (Single Photo Emission Computed Tomography) scan. At http://www.hbot4u.com/brainscans.html you can see SPECT scan pictures of a 17 year old boys brain who had autism, poor grades, poor social skills, and seizures. The scan looks at blood flow/activity of the brain, and its quantified across the rainbow/spectrum of color. Purple/blue is low flow and activity- those dormant sleeping neurons, through green, and up to yellow into red with intensification to white being high flow/activity. The second set of pictures as you scroll down this web page is his brain a year after he completed 50 sessions. You can see the dramatic increases in the front of the brain where social skills live, and the sides of the brain where language lives.
Note that this young mans sessions were stopped after 50- although there was dramatic improvement in his SPECT scan, it didnt light up all areas of the brain- would other areas have improved with more time? With lower pressures and less O2 in the mild chambers that are FDA approved for use in the home, we can potentially continue daily treatment indefinitely. The possibility of continued steady improvement is very real and in fact, our long term patients give testimony to ongoing improvements that constantly evolve.
Is this the magic bullet weve been awaiting?
Mild hyperbaric oxygen will not be the panacea. Once revitalized, the brain cells still have to be trained to do what they were intended to do (i.e. therapy) and theyll still need ongoing metabolic support (nutrition and vitamin supplementation) to complete their rehabilitation. Remember too, that the brain is only one area that needs healing in our children. That being said, oxygen is critical to most processes within the human body and perhaps the best description of its role will be to augment to every therapy and treatment a child is offered.
What are we doing to figure out how hyperbaric oxygen helps our children?
A myriad of research is needed. Thoughtful House, Pediatric Partners of Ponte Vedra, and the Hyperbaric Therapy Center have initiated an evaluation of how mild hyperbaric oxygen influences characteristics of autism. ATEC (Autism Treatment Evaluation Checklist- a severity rating scale of several symptoms often associated with autism developed by the Autism Research Institute) ratings will be monitored regularly over the course of treatment with mild hyperbaric oxygen. We have three children who had SPECT brain scans before starting therapy and they will repeat them after 40 sessions. Based on other SPECT scan before and after results, we anticipate that there will be improvements on these childrens SPECT scans as others have seen before, and that there will be correlating improvements in their ATEC scores quantifying the plethora of parental and physician testimony to often dramatic improvement in our children.
If we indeed document these two changes on a small scale study, then one would be tempted to infer that the children who werent scanned but did have improved ATEC scores had similar improvements in their brain flow and activity. This will prompt larger scale longer term studies and hopefully funding to support them. Once begun on this path, others will surely begin to probe into the effects on, at the least, the impact of mild hyperbaric oxygen on immune function and gut health.
So whats the bottom line?
We know that our children have sustained benefit from 20, 30, and 40 sessions of mild hyperbaric oxygen. Testimonials of parents and physicians have documented this and research needs to confirm it. I suspect that if we continue to use mild hyperbaric oxygen over the course of a childs lifetime, in daily doses of one to two hours a day, we may eventually be able to revitalize much of their dormant brain tissue. I also suspect we will find positive impact on immune function and gut healing. I do not yet know if the oxygen alone will detoxify a child (I suspect not, but it may facilitate other agents doing that eventually). There is a tremendous amount to learn in this area, but I strongly suspect that mild hyperbaric oxygen therapy has quite a role to play in getting our children healthy and ready to take an active role in society.